159 Comments
User's avatar
Thomas's avatar

Israel is not Judaism. Criticism of Israel is not antisemitism. Palestine is not Hamas. The desire for revenge, or self-defense does not justify genocide.

Expand full comment
DJ's avatar

💯

Expand full comment
Molly Ciliberti's avatar

Criticizing the Israeli government is not antisemitic. Netanyahu is committing genocide on Gaza. My Jewish great grandmother would be appalled that Israel is doing this. Jews of all people should not do this.I feel for the thousands of Israelis who oppose Netanyahu.

Expand full comment
Thomas's avatar

Thank you Molly for writing. Respectful greetings to your great grandmother. I feel that she is looking at us with kindness. Thomas

Expand full comment
ZyklonBee's avatar

BULLSHIT... over 80% of Jews support the Gaza Genocide. You're a race of lying, scheming, genocidal monsters. https://archive.org/details/davidirvingtheholocaustlie_201908

Expand full comment
Molly Ciliberti's avatar

You just hate Jews and love Nazis.

Expand full comment
User was indefinitely suspended for this comment. Show
Expand full comment
Roger Kimber, MD's avatar

There is NO genocide in Gaza. The Gazans have made their bed with Hamas , many willingly function as human shields for Hamas. You are an ignorant person. I hope you aren’t Jewish.

Expand full comment
2ASupporter78's avatar

The instrument of. Genocide lies with Hamas.

Expand full comment
Priscilla A Clore's avatar

Well said.

Expand full comment
Majesterial Joy's avatar

This.

Expand full comment
ZyklonBee's avatar

Jews are The Devil. Israel is their parasitic patch of Hell leaching off of White countries with child rape blackmail schemes. It's time to kick y'all not just out of America but off of the Planet. https://archive.org/details/davidirvingtheholocaustlie_201908

Expand full comment
KillWill's avatar

Anti-Zionism is the Denial of the right for the Jewish nation to exist. For example If you denied the Japanese or indian people’s right to have Japan or India but say well they’re still cool people, it’s kinda a lame way of saying, fuck your country but you’re still cool. I guess I could go on, but I’ll stop there.

Expand full comment
Rebeca Neria's avatar

Isnt that what Israel is doing to the Palestinian ppl? Zionists created apartheid state not a Jewish nation to exist. And if they felt how u are saying then why a genocide a ethnic cleanse

Expand full comment
KillWill's avatar

Ok, Look up the root word Palestine. It was a name given by the Romans after they drove the Jews out of the land. They named it Syria Palestina

In their Latin translation Palestine was derived from phillistines a previous enemy of Judea as Rome glorified. All this Jew-hatred is simply Roman muscle memory passed down after they banned them from Entering Jerusalem after building their pagan temples over the dust of synagogues and the high temple they destroyed.

It has been Jewish land for millennia, no amount of hatred and genocide accusations will drive them from their land again, whether from European forces or Islamic forces. Never again is now.

I don’t like to swear, and I’m sorry but Fuck your modern definition of Zionism. Zionism is a fuel for the spiritual warfare from forces trying to destroy the Jewish people and uproot their God given sovereignty. Zionism is the shield from God to defend a ppl and a nation from destruction. This is nothing new.

Expand full comment
Thomas's avatar

In your view does being anti-genocide equate to denying the right of Israel to exist?

Expand full comment
Molly Ciliberti's avatar

Ridiculous! I am an American but I hate my Trump led Republican government. If you can’t recognize me as separate from my government then the onus is on you. Israel is a country, genocide is being committed by the Netanyahu government, two different things. The Israeli people are not their government. Think!

Expand full comment
ZyklonBee's avatar

WRONG: over 80% of Jews in Israel SUPPORT, Bibi. Stop trying to fool The Goyim. We're done feeling sorry for you over your fake "holocaust". https://archive.org/details/davidirvingtheholocaustlie_201908

Expand full comment
Molly Ciliberti's avatar

Not true. Have you seen the thousands in the streets protesting. You just hate Jews.

Expand full comment
KillWill's avatar

Doesn’t matter if Israelis like Netanyahu or not, even weeks before he took military action this global “anti-Zionist” sentiment quickly descended into targeting Jewish students on their campuses. So, no I feel they’re fighting for their own existence. This is far beyond not liking your current govt at this point.

Expand full comment
Molly Ciliberti's avatar

I stand by my comment. It isn’t my fault that stupid people looking for any excuse to hate Jews are now rearing their ugly heads. Anti- Zionist is not necessarily anti-Semitic since there are people who are still angry that Palestinians were removed from their ancestral land to make Israel. If you are American, how would you feel if the indigenous people of your area reclaimed the land you live on.

Expand full comment
KillWill's avatar

Israel has been the land of the Jewish people for over 5000 years if you’ve had any biblical knowledge you’d maybe understand its roots and ancestral lineage. It isn’t the same as America with native territories as such, to your point you briefly mentioned. Palestine was acquired by the Ottoman Empire and General Salahudein during the crusades where both Muslim and Christian nations used their own religious symbols and ideas solely for the purposes of conquest and land in the post Roman Empire period. The Jews were chased out by the Romans 72 AD during the Rome/Judea wars. And have tried time and time to return to their homeland to at least worship God/Hashem, but faced nothing but hostility and persecution throughout history. But I understand the reality that many people do have a different perspective on Zionism whether political or spiritual, however many demonize it and link it to one political leader or another they may dislike and redefine it as some sort of fascist idea or concept. And the people who are hating Jews in the wake of Oct 7th are trying to wrap themselves in banners of left-leaning causes thinking that they are not perpetuating anti-Semitism. The woke left to me and the woke right are both trash. Everyone to Kanye West, Candace Owens, coke head Dan Bilzerian, and the super leftist college students all infiltrated with this jew-hatred, it’s just a different angle and perspective they get it from that riles em up about a current conflict they become passionately connected to. No one’s trying to frame them as anti-semites, their own fury is doing the work for them. I’m sorry they’ve been brainwashed to believe the Hamas media death toll and narratives.

Expand full comment
Molly Ciliberti's avatar

Israel has been the home land of the Palestinians just as long. Remember supposedly Abraham came there from what is now Iraq. No the Bible is a book written by men that is not an actual history and archeologists have not found evidence for King David’s rich kingdom. I know you don’t believe it, but millions of us do not believe in a god or your Bible. So again I state that being against Netanyahu and the Israeli government is not antisemitism nor anti the state of Israel and its people. I am not responsible for anyone except me. Can you understand that?

Expand full comment
Rebecca K's avatar

Yes!

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment deleted
Jul 2
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
Glen Liberman's avatar

Yup.

Expand full comment
Thomas's avatar

Thank you for your comment.

Expand full comment
Rachael Baker's avatar

I would trust this man, a Muslim, more than any Congressional Republicans, Trump, and all of Trumps administration!

Expand full comment
Judy In Disguise…'s avatar

Word!

Expand full comment
Iron Fist's avatar

Sure you would. Thats the kind of evil Bolsheviks are.

Expand full comment
Diana Chapman's avatar

I get it

Expand full comment
J Jo's avatar

Me too!

Expand full comment
2ASupporter78's avatar

You don’t live in NYC, do you? Do you have “skin” in the game? Talk to me when your city is facing a communist antisemite.

Expand full comment
Rachael Baker's avatar

I’m not on NYC, I live in red Arizona, i see what your concern is regarding taxing the businesses, and the cascade of issues that follow. Thank you for responding

Expand full comment
2ASupporter78's avatar

If you destroy businesses, people are out of work. That’s capitalism. Show me a place where socialism works.

Expand full comment
2ASupporter78's avatar

Ms. Baker, Mamdani will single handedly chase the tax base out of New York City. I live in Queens NY and fear for my fellow New Yorkers if this Marxist Islamist wins.

Expand full comment
Rachael Baker's avatar

Can you explain please?

Expand full comment
dikran Tulaine's avatar

So we must run our cities to keep the middle classes happy. Good old classism. Again and forever. I suppose it’s an improvement over running them to keep the billionaires happy. Which was the whine I heard.

Expand full comment
2ASupporter78's avatar

Here’s the deal: Mamdani gets in, raises taxes on businesses that employ many New Yorkers. He raises taxes on the middle class. The middle class sees their housing values drop and then move out of the City. There goes your tax base. The City then goes broke just like in the mid-70’s.

Expand full comment
M. C. Barlow's avatar

Good. My Jewish friends hate Netanyahu. They are ashamed of his campaign of terror. He went too far in response to the barbaric Oct. 7 terror attack by Hamas. He murdered innocent Palestinians. No decent Jewish person wants that.

Expand full comment
Judy In Disguise…'s avatar

As a Jew, i concur!

Expand full comment
Paul Dixon's avatar

I could not give a fk about Palestinians or Gaza

As for Jews working for Hamas ; well they will come for YOU

Just like the German nationalists

Useful idiot

Expand full comment
Elsie_Mandel's avatar

Thank you for posting this.

Expand full comment
Judy In Disguise…'s avatar

If only I still lived in NYC, this Jew would totally vote for him…! It’s what he brings to the table, HIS IDEAS, NOT, his religious beliefs or the color of his skin!

Expand full comment
Michael Ann Ochs's avatar

Thank God he has the courage to speak plainly about this when so few do.

Expand full comment
J Jo's avatar

Bc God is always with the righteous!

Expand full comment
C Endres's avatar

We need him right now. If a billionaire is against him then we need to double down and be for him. The ballots need to be hand counted.

Expand full comment
Christine's avatar

It is time to get away from religious prejudice and think of HUMANITY as one. No more factions.

Expand full comment
Kimberly's avatar

Granddaughter of Holocaust survivor. That is why I support Palestine and hate Netanyahu. Fuck him and everyone who supports him.

Expand full comment
2ASupporter78's avatar

Kimberly, don’t tempt your fate. As a Righteous Gentile, they’ll come for you and when they’ve slaughtered all the Hews, they’ll come for me.

Expand full comment
Iron Fist's avatar

The filthy trashy Bolsheviks made Hitler look like a amateur. That trash eradicated 66 million White Soviet mostly Christians. I'm glad Christians dont spend day and night crying about it.

Expand full comment
Jacobs-Meadway Roberta's avatar

Brad Lander cross-endorsed him. He cross-endorsed Brad Lander. Objecting to what is happening in Gaza should not be disqualifying for a candidate for mayor in NYC. Being a declared democratic socialist (not a Marxist) should not be disqualifying. Voters will decide what matters to them.

Expand full comment
2ASupporter78's avatar

He’s a Marxist as he has stated that his ultimate goal would be to seize the means of production.

Expand full comment
Jacobs-Meadway Roberta's avatar

Love the comedy. The facts when you get tired of making jokes.

Expand full comment
Jay  Kinard's avatar

The choice is not Jew/Islam!

The choice is new, fresh ideas or same old stuff again that isn’t working for voters!

Expand full comment
J Jo's avatar

They just like to bring his religion as if he will enforce the sharia’s law on us!

Expand full comment
Clarissa Sr, American Grandma's avatar

👆🏼👆🏼👆🏼👆🏼👆🏼

📢 Grandparents, We Must Sound the Alarm: Our Tax Dollars Are Funding a Police State

Dear Beloved Grandparents,

It’s time we speak plainly.

As we sit around our kitchen tables, our children and grandchildren are being forced to grow up in a country that is sliding closer and closer to authoritarian rule — and we are being made to fund it.

⚠️ The Senate’s version of Trump’s “Big Beautiful Reconciliation Bill” includes massive ICE funding — funneling billions of our tax dollars into:

Masked federal agents in unmarked vans

Coordinated, abusive raids in communities across the country

The kidnapping of long-time residents — including legal immigrants — under vague suspicions

A growing federal police force operating with no transparency or civil rights oversight

This is not border security. This is state-sponsored terror, paid for by working Americans like you and me.

And it gets worse.

During a recent visit with El Salvador’s president, Trump boasted about plans to deport “homegrown” people — a chilling phrase that should strike fear in any true patriot. It implies citizens — born and raised here — could be targeted for political reasons, ethnicity, activism, or simple dissent.

Let us be clear: this is the language of fascism.

We’ve read about this in history books. Hitler’s party didn’t start with death camps. It started by vilifying immigrants, imprisoning critics, and passing laws that funded paramilitary forces while silencing opposition — all under the guise of “order.”

That is the road we are now on.

🛑 But we can still turn around — if we act now.

✅ Call your U.S. Senators and Representatives. Demand they vote no on this ICE expansion buried in Trump’s reconciliation bill.

✅ Support independent media — they are uncovering what corporate outlets are ignoring. Share, subscribe, and spread the truth.

✅ Educate your family and neighbors — especially young voters and those raised on right-wing news.

✅ Remind your communities: We’ve seen this before. We must never be silent again.

📣 Grandparents — we are the protectors of memory and the guardians of democracy.

Let us honor that duty now.

🇺🇸 Peaceful resistance. Public truth. People before power.

In Solidarity,

Clarissa Sr, an American Grandma

#GrandparentsForDemocracy #IndependentMediaMatters #DefundICE #StopThePoliceState #GoodTrouble #ProtectOurFuture

Expand full comment
GBH's avatar

Your grandchildren are being transgendered and socialised as neo communists… fascist are the lesser evil … at least you can see and recognise them

Expand full comment
TheCorbster's avatar

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂MAYBE YOU SHOULD TRY PULLING YOUR HEAD OUT YOUR ORANGE GOD’S ASS…🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡

Expand full comment
Iron Fist's avatar

To bad you are so stupid, or a commie satanist POS.

Expand full comment
GBH's avatar

He’s not my president- literally as I’m not a US citizen!

Nor is he my or anyone’s god… except in the head of TDS sufferers! 🤡

Expand full comment
TheCorbster's avatar

If ORANGINA is not your prez because you are not a citizen …then STFU… if you do NOT know wtf you are talking about.. STFU. Half of the MAGAT MORONS that voted for ORANGINA HITLER DO believe he is the second coming of christ….. ( apparently when you’re a fucking moron you’ll believe anything a shyster tells you)

Expand full comment
GBH's avatar

Yep - I’ve been watching Reacher and they have a running gag about people using profanity and their IQ…

Expand full comment
TheCorbster's avatar

😂😂…doesnt Reacher also say….if you dont have a clue as to what you are flapping your lips about you should shut up and let people wonder about your intelligence rather than prove your ignorance?

Expand full comment
Lynn Van Haren's avatar

Criticism of Netanyahu & his war crimes is NOT antisemitism!

Expand full comment
Eileen Vandernoot's avatar

He does not think that Jewish people should have their own state. Meanwhile 40 or so Arab state have Muslim countries! So, it seems to me that he is anti Jew!

Expand full comment
Tony Karon's avatar

Do most Jewish people believe we should have our own state? Wouldn't appear so given that the majority of us have chosen, quite freely, not to live in this state. To me, it's anti-Jewish to hold us responsible for the criminal actions of a regime that claims to represent us, but which we have not chosen. And your argument about Muslim countries falls flat, obviously (I heard the same thing in South Africa from defenders of the apartheid regime, i.e that there were so many Black countries, and just this one white supremacist one...) Israel was created on land where Jews were not a majority, so its founders violently ejected the Palestinian majority. That's the source of the conflict. So, no, Zohran is not anti-Jew, and tens of thousands of Jewish New Yorkers voted for him. Many many thousands of Jews want nothing to do with apartheid, and Israel is an apartheid state.

Expand full comment
Eileen Vandernoot's avatar

If you ANYTHING about Israel you would know that Arabs, Christians and Druz live and work along side of Jews everyday. You are uneducated with the world of Israel. With the rights of every other citizen in Israel regardless of their ethnicity.

Expand full comment
2ASupporter78's avatar

Any way you slice it, Mamdani is a Marxist Islamist. Be honest with yourself.

Expand full comment
J Jo's avatar

Bigotry. Gi read to disgusting Talmud!

Expand full comment
2ASupporter78's avatar

Antisemite

Expand full comment
Eileen Vandernoot's avatar

Live and let live is one of the great mottos of the people of Israel!!

Expand full comment
J Jo's avatar

So wrong!

Expand full comment
2ASupporter78's avatar

💯

Expand full comment
ER's avatar

The Jewish voters who voted for him are fooling themselves.

Expand full comment
Cat Adams's avatar

It’s not anti Semitism, is anti-Zionism !

Expand full comment
Ron Bradley's avatar

Sick showing their true colors

Expand full comment