I’ve seen a lot of social-media noise criticizing the “NAZA” film as if it had stolen attention from “Citizen Osama”, the harrowing Palestinian film documenting the lived experience of Gaza suffering the very war crimes confessed to in NAZA. Or dismissing it as more “shooting-and-crying”, the Israeli-centered idiom of an earlier, less overtly Nazified generation seeking Western liberal sympathy for the violence they unleashed on Palestinians. And I saw in such criticism both a profound misreading of the film’s intention and impact, and — from what I learned in South Africa’s liberation struggle — what appears to be strategically misguided approach to the struggle for justice and liberation between the River and the Sea in Palestine.
The past three years have made painfully clear that Palestine won’t be liberated or even saved by winning a contest over virtue or visibility on social media — a liberation struggle is always, primarily, a struggle over power, and social media is a simulacrum rather than a site of actual power. Power is not simply a tool — it’s a relationship between contending, irreconcilable social and political forces, always in some kind of dynamic balance. Today that balance not only sustains the grotesque apartheid genocide in Palestine, but actually allows the Israelis to pursue the full erasure of Palestine with greater ferocity than at any point in its history. Restraints on Israeli actions and ambitions that might have been there 25 years ago have been blown away by this century’s changing global and regional dynamics.
The history of all liberation struggles teaches that success requires on decisively shifting the balance of power – in Palestine, from one that today allows the apartheid-genocide regime to impose its ghastly agenda, to one that allows the dismantling of that regime.
While Twitter, Instagram and Tik-Tok have made Palestine’s reality more visible than ever and spurred unprecedented citizen solidarity, the genocide grinds on. Despite the value of those platforms in allowing hundreds of millions to bear witness to the genocide, Palestine can’t be freed or even saved on Twitter, Instagram or Tik-Tok any more than liberation can be won in a video game. Those platforms also amplify a “militant” posturing that functions as an emotionally satisfying fetish of resistance, but with zero impact on the ground where Palestinian bodies are savaged daily by Israeli military power; where more Palestinian land is stolen every day; and where the balance of force currently leans more towards the Zionists completing their Nakba project than towards Palestine being liberated between River and Sea.
Palestine will not freed, even saved, if Ro Khanna bowed to the bizarre obsession in some quarters of the Twitter Fight Club with having him endorse the Palestinian right to armed resistance. It won’t be saved, as Rashid Khalidi warns, by social media feed-ayeen setting up imaginary moral roadblocks to check the revolutionary credentials of anyone whose position the genocide seems to be moving, albeit late and only partly. Nor will the genocidaires be “denormalized” out of existence — notice how little it meant to Netanyahu’s performance at the UNGA that more than 100 delegations walked out: He simply incorporated their gesture into his braggadocio shtick demonstrating to his electorate the impunity he enjoys in the West.
Effective liberation activism is grounded in a coherent strategy, the science of victory. Strategy requires a blunt assessment of the real strengths, limits and vulnerabilities of one’s own forces and those of the adversary on all relevant political terrains. That allows the movement to choose which battles to prioritize, and where and when to fight them, based on how their results advance the overall political goals of the struggle. (Things change, and a movement unable to respond to both the opportunities and the perils represented by those changes risks oblivion.)
The balance of forces is a single equation, and shifting it in favor of the liberation project requires work at both ends, not only to unite and strengthen the liberation camp but also to divide and weaken the oppressor camp.
In South Africa, this meant not only organizing and empowering those oppressed by the apartheid system and ready to march for full emancipation, and bolstering their power by enlisting allies who would march alongside them even temporarily, or on a limited agreement on an immediate issue or crisis. It also meant paying close attention to dynamics, divisions and ruptures in the regime’s camp — divisions that could potentially be widened, to isolate the most dangerous enemy from allies he’d relied on.
An example would be the demand to withdraw the regime’s troops from South Africa’s Black townships: That objective was shared by all township residents, regardless of their attitude to the overall liberation project. But that demand also potentially resonated across the apartheid divide: Many young white men, conscripted into the regime’s army, had no appetite to fight a civil war on behalf of apartheid, and could be won over to the limited demand of keeping the army out of the townships. For some that was the beginning of a journey into the liberation movement, which promised a shared post-apartheid future based on justice and equality for all South Africans. But turning the regime’s conscripts into ANC activists was a rare bonus; the strategic value of engaging white communities the troops-in-the-township issue at the same time as organizing the resistance of the Black community was that it eroded the morale and cohesion of the regime’s base, turning many more than would be willing to support the ANC away from the regime’s efforts to militarily eliminate the liberation forces in the townships.
Even simply shifting white conscripts from the regime’s camp to a neutral column had an important effect on the regime’s coherence and morale. The regime relied not only on its hardcore white Afrikaner nationalist base for its survival; it also had to convince the English-speaking 40% of the white population that their interests lay in sustaining apartheid. It needed the backing of the country’s corporate sector and Churches; and it relied on Cold War support from the Western powers. The liberation movement worked in all of these sectors to chip away at the props on which the system rested, to weaken the apartheid camp.
So, how would such a framework help us assess the value of the NAZA film?
Start from the reality that Israel is literally getting away with murder, pushing to entirely erase Palestine from its land — and facing no material restraint or consequence for such doing so. In concert with the U.S. it has completely obliterated the legal and administrative frameworks of the United Nations and international law; its genocide has the support of 80% the Jewish Israeli population. They may oust Netanyahu in next month’s election, but any successor would pursue the same policies. They are backed to the hilt by the arms and political protection of the U.S. (including the Democratic Party establishment). And they are enabled by feckless passivity and worse by European and Arab regimes. Most of global civil society is appalled by what Israel is doing, but very few governments are prepared risk confrontation with the United States, which is what holding Israel accountable requires, as South Africa’s ICJ case made clear.
The unprecedented support for Palestine in global civil society would be potentially decisive in a democratic world, but most of today’s governments are more responsive to the demands of capital markets and big powers than to their own citizens — their response to citizen outrage over Gaza has been painfully slow, and always inadequate. The gulf between power and legitimacy has never, in my lifetime, been wider.
Still, as grim as the balance of forces stacked against Palestinian freedom may be right now, it reflects a world system that is unsustainable. The human spirit of Palestinian resilience has always thwarted Zionist erasure, and today inspires global resistance to the entire neoliberal project. In the U.S. today, voters are increasingly choosing candidates who openly stand for justice in Palestine, not necessarily because of that stance, but because those are the candidates promising to fight the same oligarchy (which is uniformly aligned with Israel) whose greed-driven rule has made life increasingly unaffordable for the majority of Americans. It’s not necessarily that support for Palestine is winning elections; it’s that support for Palestine is no longer a disqualifier in the U.S. political mainstream, while taking campaign donations from the Israel lobby is now viewed in the mainstream as signifying a candidate’s moral corruption.
There are plenty of fissures and potential cracks in that balance of forces that has enabled the genocide. And efforts to widen those, divide and weaken the “pro-Israel” consensus that underwrites Israeli impunity — even very limited steps like the U.K. government adopting sanctions against settlements, but at the same time also recognizing the legal authority of the ICC at a moment when the U.S. and Israel are trying to destroy it — potentially do more good than harm if encouraged and pushed beyond their more limited early steps. It’s very easy to say — and substantially correct — that such steps are outrageously little, and outrageously late, given what we know. But simply declaring that with thumbs blasting away on Twitter runs the risk of it being little more than an epitaph for Palestine.
So, the important questions on the impact of the NAZA film would be:
—Does it strengthen or weaken the liberation camp;
—Does it weaken or strengthen the apartheid genocide camp?
—Does it have no relevant impact at all?
Obviously, if it had no relevant impact, it wouldn’t have sparked a major freakout among Israeli and Western stakeholders — the response from Israeli government and society has been apoplectic. That’s because the confessions to war crimes by their Israeli perpetrators can’t be as easily dismissed in those circles via their racist dismissal of the truth when spoken by Palestinians
So, yes, of course Yuval Avraham and Rachel Szor are privileged by Israel’s apartheid system. But it’s how they’ve used that privilege — the access it gives them to other Jewish Israelis, and how that privileged status shatters the denial-mechanism of many more liberal Israelis and their Western supporters — that potentially weakens the very structure that privileged them.
Marion Sparg, the white ANC guerrilla who bombed the headquarters of the apartheid South African police in March 1986 used the privilege assigned to her by the apartheid system to smuggle a limpet mine into that building; Yuval and Rachel used the privileged access accorded them by Israel’s apartheid system to assemble and detonate a truth bomb inside the belly of the beast.
Their target audience is clearly Israelis in denial about what their society is doing — and if it persuades more to publicly protest, or refuse to serve in a genocidal army, that will have objectively weakened the genocide camp. It’s also aimed at Western elites who squeal that “it’s complicated” and aggressively deny that Israel’s savaging of Gaza is genocide, the film is a body blow. They refuse to believe Palestinians out of racist deference to Jewish Israelis; here, they’re seeing a representative sample of Jewish Israeli intelligence officers confirming the Palestinian truths Israel and its supporters have been desperate to deny.
The hysteria the film has triggered throughout Israeli society, and among its supporters in the U.S., reflects a fear that film breaches the bubble of denial that helps sustain Israel’s impunity.
Will NAZA end the genocide? Of course not. But could it chip away at the consensus that sustains it? Quite possibly. And does it weaken the liberation camp by centering Israeli voices? Only if one imagines the struggle to liberate Palestine simply as a shouting contest on social media. NAZA literally went where apartheid prevents any Palestinian film from going, and it does work inside the enemy camp that no Palestinian film could do. It’s aimed at an audience unmoved by such powerful testaments as “Citizen Osama”, “Gaza: Doctors Under Attack” or the excellent, harrowing films made by my Jazeera colleagues.
Israel sees this film as dangerous because morally decrepit Western liberals insisting that Israel be given the (colonial racist) benefit of the doubt will find it harder to sustain the lies that justify continuing to shield it from accountability when so many of the perpetrators are confessing their own role in war crimes. It’s precisely the fear that what the film shows could weaken the bubble of impunity around the genocide that drives Israel’s hysteria over NAZA.

Very well written, peace and love to you. Hopefully Palestinians can elect a pragmatic moderate like Samer Sinijlawi or Marwan Barghoutti's son on a platform of a two state partition similar to the 2008 Olmert plan to end the occupation, and a combination of international pressure and internal desire for no more war will result in Israeli politics responding favorably.
Well expressed and erudite commentary that answers one issue -- the benefits of NAZA, as a film -- and leaves open an answer to the significant question -- how do we stop the ongoing genocide? I expect many would appreciate a response to that anguishing question, which seems to have eluded the universe, for not just these last three years, but since 1948. Is it because we feel sorry, but don't feel committed, or don't want to accept what has to be done because it reveals undoing complicit actions in the past?